The entity decision gets made in about twenty minutes, usually by someone who has never made it before, often on a filing service website at eleven at night. Then the company lives inside it for ten years.
I have incorporated companies on three continents and unwound two structures that were wrong from the start. The unwinding is the expensive part. Not because the filing fee is large, but because by the time you know the structure is wrong, you have a cap table, a payroll, a lender, and a tax history sitting on top of it.
What follows is the shape of the decision, not advice about your situation. I am not an attorney and not an accountant. Your lawyer and your CPA put in the numbers. What I can tell you is which questions actually move the answer, because most of what gets written about this answers the wrong ones.
The three options, in operator terms
Forget the legal definitions for a moment. The practical difference between the three is who pays the tax and when you can’t change your mind.
The LLC is the flexible one. Profits pass through to you, and you pay tax on them whether or not the money left the company, which surprises founders in their first profitable year when they have no cash. It is cheap to form, light to maintain, and it can elect to be taxed as an S corporation later without changing what the entity is.
The S corporation is a tax election rather than a kind of company. Its appeal is that you split what you take out into salary and distribution, and the distribution side avoids self-employment tax. Its cost is that you now run payroll, pay yourself a defensible wage, and accept hard limits on who may own you: a capped number of shareholders, individuals only, US persons only, and one class of stock.
The C corporation pays its own tax, and then you pay again on what it distributes. Every founder hears that and stops reading. It is also the only one of the three that an institutional investor can put money into without a conversation they would rather not have, the only one that issues the preferred stock those investors expect, and the only one where qualified small business stock treatment is even on the table.
The question that decides it
Not “which saves me the most tax this year.” That question has a clear answer, and it is usually the wrong structure.
The question is who you expect to own a piece of this in five years. Everything else follows from it.
- Only you, or you and a partner, indefinitely. An LLC, with an S election once the profit is large enough that the payroll overhead pays for itself. Your accountant can tell you roughly where that line sits for your numbers.
- Employees you will want to give equity to. This is where the LLC gets uncomfortable. Profit interests work, but they are harder to explain, harder to value, and every good hire will have to be walked through something they haven’t seen before.
- Outside investors, at any point. A Delaware C corporation, and sooner rather than later. Converting under a term sheet is a cost and a delay at the exact moment you have neither to spare.
The two mistakes I see most
Electing S too early. A founder reads about self-employment tax, makes the election, and eighteen months later takes a meeting with someone who wants to write a check. An S corporation cannot have that investor. It cannot have a fund, another company, or, in most cases, a foreign national. Now the structure has to change while the diligence clock runs.
Forming a C corporation for a business that will never raise. The reverse mistake, and it is quieter. A consultancy or an agency that throws off profit and has no intention of selling equity to anyone pays its own corporate tax, then pays again to get the money out, and files more to do it. This one tends to persist for years because nothing breaks. It just costs.
What changing it later actually costs
The direction matters. LLC to C corporation is a well-worn path, and your lawyer has done it many times. Going the other way, C corporation back to something lighter, can be a taxable event on the way out, and the bill is calculated on what the company is worth rather than what you have in the bank.
Which is the real argument for spending an hour on this at the start. Not that the first choice is permanent. The cost of reversing it isn’t symmetrical, and you take the expensive direction once the company has finally started working.
The part nobody files
A structure is a container. What goes wrong more often than the container being the wrong shape is that nothing is set up inside it: no chart of accounts that matches how the business actually earns, no separation between the owner and the company at the bank, and no books a lender or buyer could read without a translator.
I have watched a sound business lose a credit line because its books could not answer a question in the week it was asked. The entity was fine. The accounting underneath it had been improvised for four years.
Choose the structure for who will own the company. Then spend the real effort on the system that runs inside it.
Incorporation and structure are where most of my startup engagements begin, together with the accounting and operations setup that sits under it. If you are at that decision now, it is worth half an hour before it is worth a filing fee.
